26 May 2018

PinkFae Archive #13: Board Game Review: Area 1851

It is time once more for a PinkFae archive. This one is another board game review that I wrote for that site. This article was originally published on 27 March 2016.

The cover art of Area 1851, showing an old west style town with a banner across the street that displays the title, and in the foreground, a cowboy hovering by means of a jetpack shakes hands with an alien holding a pickaxe.

The time has come once again for a board game review. This week, I shall look at a new game that was only just recently published, with the help of Kickstarter, and was introduced to me by my good friend John Trobare. The game in question is: Area 1851. It is a game of 'UFOs meet cowboys.' Aliens and old west characters are competing to gain the greatest amount of reputation by constructing and delivering strange devices.

As always, we start with some numerals that are not at all randomly generated.

Strategy and Randomness are rated from 0 to 6. A 0 means the rated aspect plays no part in determining the game's outcome; and a 6 means that it is the only factor that determines the game's outcome. Complexity is also rated from 0 to 6; a 0 means that it's so simple a six-year-old can play it, a 3 means any adult should have no trouble playing, and a 6 means that you'll need to refer to the rulebook frequently. Humour can be rated as 'None,' meaning the game is not meant to be funny, or it may have one or more of the following: Derivative (meaning the humour is based on an outside source, such as a game based on a comedy film), Implicit (meaning that the game's components are funny, such as humourous card text), or Inherent (meaning that the actions the players take are funny). Attractiveness has nine possible ratings. Ideal: the game is beautiful and makes game play easier. Pretty: The design is beautiful and neither eases nor impedes game play. Nice: The design is beautiful but makes game play harder than necessary. Useful: The design is neither beautiful nor ugly, but eases gameplay. Average: The design is neither beautiful nor ugly, and neither eases nor impedes gameplay. Useless: The design is neither beautiful nor ugly, but makes gameplay harder than it needs to be. Utilitarian: The design is ugly, but eases gameplay. Ugly: The design is ugly, and neither eases nor impedes gameplay. Worthless: The design is ugly, and makes gameplay harder than it needs to be. Average Length of Game Play describes how long an average game will probably last, give or take.
Strategy: 2
Randomness: 4
Complexity: 2
Humour: Implicit
Attractiveness: Pretty
Average Length of Gameplay: 1 hour

General Game Play

I hesitate to call Area 1851 a board game, because in many ways, the board is almost superfluous. It has a scoring track around the edge, and artwork depicting five locations within the old west town. Almost all of the action in the game itself occurs with cards.

But I digress. Let me describe how the game works: there are three types of cards: Event, Feat, and Tinker. The Tinker cards are most important; they are what drives most of the action of the game. These cards represent either a gadget or a modification. The whole point of the game is to assemble devices by adding modifications to gadgets, and then to deliver them, which earns you reputation (which is really just the word that this game uses instead of 'victory points'). Feat cards offer additional ways to earn reputation, and event cards create one-turn-only conditions, such as rules modifications, limitations, bonuses, and so forth.

Here's how Area 1851 works in a little more detail. First, the players draw an event card. This describes what weird variations will affect the players this round. Second, all players draw until they have a hand of five tinker cards. They also roll 3d4. In the third phase, players have two action points that they may use. There are four possible actions they may take with these action points:

  • Fabricate: assign dice to a gadget card in your hand to put it into play.
  • Attach: assign dice to a modification card in your hand to add it to one of your devices already in play.
  • Feat: draw a feat card.
  • Scrap: place one or more of your tinker cards into your scrap pile.
In addition to these actions, players may activate their workers (more on these in a moment), and/or alter the result of a single die by 1 point at the price of discarding a card from their scrap pile. These two actions do not cost an action point.

Once this has been done, you move on to the delivery phase, where players may discard devices they have in play to earn the listed reputation points. The turn ends with players moving their assistants back to the idle spaces and passing their hand of tinker cards to the next player.


There's a little more depth to Area 1851, though. The two most important extra details are the devices and the workers.


As mentioned, there are two types of tinker cards: gadgets and modifications. But these come in three types: alien, cowboy, and native.  There are also some that are neutral; they have no type. This is only important because if you deliver a device that is full and is made up of all the same type (e.g., all cards making up a device are alien cards), then you get double points for that device. Also, some of the feat cards can grant you bonus points depending on the type of cards in the device.

Each card has a cost and a point value. To play any card, you must assign one or more dice to that card in the Fabricate or Attach actions. The value of the dice must be equal to (not greater than!) the cost listed on that card. Thus, if you have a card with a cost of 3, you can assign a single die showing a result of 3, or a pair of dice that total 3, or even all three of your dice if they all have a 1. This is why the 'fiddle' free action (discarding a tinker card to alter the value of a die by 1 point) is so important: if you need to spend 3 points, but you rolled all 2s and 4s, you can't use any of those dice to equal 3 without using the 'fiddle' free action.

Each gadget card has up to three attachment points. Each modification card has exactly one attachment point. A modification card can only be attached to a gadget card that has the same attachment point. So if your gadget card has the circle and the square attachment points, but not the triangle point, you can't attach a modification card that has the triangle point.

You can deliver any device during the delivery phase. You gain reputation points equal to the total point values listed on all the cards (the gadget card and any attached modifications). A device is considered full if it has a modification card installed in all available attachment points (which makes the device worth double points if all cards are of the same type).


In addition to the tinker and feat cards, each player has three workers. These are represented by meeples that resemble aliens in cowboy hats. For the first five turns of the game, each player can use only one of these. After turn five, they receive a second worker. After turn ten, they receive the final worker. These workers start the turn in an idle work space on the board. There are five locations depicted on the board: the Town Hall, the Replicator, the Storehouse, the Workshop, and the Recycler. Each one has an idle work space attached to it. Your worker(s) begin a round in one of the idle work spaces. You may use a free action to activate one or more of your workers. Depending on which space the worker is on, this grants you an extra ability.

  • A worker on the Town Hall lets you sacrifice one or more of your dice for this turn in exchange for a point of reputation per die. If you have two workers here, you get two points per die.
  • A worker on the Recycler allows you to deliver a modification attached to one of your gadgets (giving you the points from that modification and freeing up an attachment point on that gadget). If you have two workers here, you can deliver a device, but instead of discarding the cards, you send them to your scrap pile.
  • A worker on the Storehouse allows you to swap a card from your hand with one from your scrap pile. If you have two workers here, you may discard a card from your scrap pile to place another card from your scrap pile directly into play without having to use dice to pay for it.
  • A worker on the Replicator allows you to discard a card and then draw two new ones to replace it. If you have two workers here, you may gain an extra action point this round.
  • A worker on the Workshop allows you to alter a single die by one point without having to discard a card from your scrap pile. If you have two workers here, you may re-roll and re-use any number of dice once on your turn.

During the Worker phase of each round, when players move their workers back to the idle work space, they must move the workers to the idle work space attached to that worker's current location. After doing this, though, they may move a single worker to any other location's idle work space.

At the end of round 15, players reveal and score any feat cards that take effect at the end of the game. Whoever has the most reputation is the winner.

Final thoughts on Area 1851

The game is amusing, primarily because the art is funny and whimsical, and the bizarre combinations of cards can make for some humorous devices (for example, you may start with the 'Self-Walking Footwear' gadget, and later add the 'Plain 'Ole' modification, the 'Horse Powered' modification, and the 'With Tribal Markings' modification, to get the 'Plain 'Ole Horse Powered Self-Walking Footwear With Tribal Markings' device.

As I said, it seems more like a card game than a board game to me, though it does have elements of a worker-placement game as well as a dash of Sushi Go thrown in for flavour (ha!). I found it vaguely amusing, and somewhat enjoyable, although the reliance on dice to give you numbers needed for the cards in your hand can be very frustrating at times (the game I played, I frequently found myself with nothing in my hand but cards that cost 9 or more to build, and the dice refused to give me any total higher than 7). I personally would be willing to play Area 1851 again on occasion, but I probably don't need to own it.

But that's just my thoughts. By all means, give it a try and decide for yourself! And until next week,

Game on!

No comments:

Post a Comment

I'll be along soon to make sure your comment isn't spam. Until then, just sit tight! Unless your comment IS spam, in which case, bugger off.